Baxandall Circuits Explained


Hi-Fi tone circuits are usually centered around 1KHz. The standard hifi tone circuit provides treble cut and bass cut. Conversely, this provides an apparent midrange boost. When I refer to the 'standard' hifi tone circuit, this usually means the 'Baxandall' circuit, credited to inventor Peter Baxandall. Maybe this post is appropriate at this time, because Baxandall has just died recently. We have him to thank for much innovation in tube amp design. Following is one of Baxandall's contributions to tone circuitry:

 

[NOTE: Use a DC-blocking cap to couple this circuit to a tube plate].

You've probably seen this circuit before in stereo amp schematics. A close look at this circuit will reveal that the bass and treble controls are almost opposite. The Bass pot (R2) and Treble pot (R5) are both large values compared to the impedance of surrounding components, so when viewing the circuit in simplified form, they can be ignored.

Visualize what is happening with the bass control: an R-C (resistor- capacitor) mid-cut (bass-boost) circuit is formed by R1/C2 when the bass pot is at max (wiper at the top). When the bass control is turned to minimum, C1/R3 form a bass cut circuit. Actually, it keeps about the same amount of midrange cut as before (flowing thru C1), but bass frequencies are shunted to ground thru R3.

The converse occurs with the treble control. This time, R4 serves as the resistance in both RC networks. At the max treble setting, C3/R4 cut mid and bass freq's (actually shunting them to the bass control which takes care of mid cut, etc). High frequencies pass straight thru C3 unimpeded. At min treble, C4/R4 still shunt bass and midrange freq's to the bass control, but now treble frequencies are shunted to ground thru C4.

 

BASS and TREBLE BOOST (MID CUT)

Consider what the circuit looks like with bass and treble at max. Keep in mind that both circuits use relatively high value pots, so they can be ignored for purposes of illustration. I've also omitted other components which are incidental to this setting.

 

 

It is usually easier to read tone control circuits from right to left. C3 allows treble to pass straight thru, but diverts bass and mid freq's thru R4. At the junction of R1/C2, the bass frequencies take the high road, while most of the mids are shunted to ground thru C2/R3.

This circuit can be related directly to a simple tone circuit that provides boost only: C3 is the 250pf treble cap, R4 is the 250K treble pot, R1 is the 100k fixed resistor, C2 is the .047 mid-cut cap, and R3 is the 6800 ohm resistor which prevents too much mid-scooping. All other components are incidental when controls are at max.

 

BASS and TREBLE CUT (MID BOOST)

This is where the similarity to the Fender control ends. When the Baxandall controls are set to min, the following circuit results. This has no equivalent Fender setting.

Now, C4 immediately shunts treble freq's to ground. Bass and mid pass thru R4. At the junction of C1/R3, mid frequencies pass thru the cap, but bass freq's are diverted to ground. Treble and Bass cut == Mid Boost.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Why don't guitar amps use the Baxandall circuit? Some do, but again, most guitarists prefer bass and treble boost. Also higher component count. And it's best to minimize the number of components in the signal path. The Fender-type circuit is simple, and if it does what you need, then stick with it. Some jazz or blues players and those looking for a bit more control may find the treble cut or 'mid boost' of the Baxandall circuit useful.

Please try to post follow-up queries, since I will not have time to reply to separate email questions. This post has already taken long enough. Darn ASCII diagrams.

Anyway, I hope this has helped to answer a few of the email queries. Sorry for the delay.

Mark Garvin
Composer/Design Engineer
New York City

 

 

 

The above text is a usenet posting made by Mark Garvin in 1995
It covers the operation of the Baxandall tone stack in some detail.
It is reprinted from Duncan's Amp Pages. Click on the banner
below to view the original, unedited text.