Audion



Circuit Review

MAGNAVOX FD1000 Compact Disc Player
     

The MAGNAVOX FD1000 compact disc player is a first generation production CD player from Philips and is identical to the CDP-101. Its predecessor is a prototype design that offered sixty minutes of playback and used both disc surfaces to do so. It had a gramophone record-ish small label at the center of the disc for album details.

 

Misty Origins

Understanding that success in the marketplace required the participation of at least one other major manufacturer, Philips invited Sony to join it in the development of the compact disc player. By the time Sony came on board, Philips had refined the disc to allow sixty minutes to be encoded on one side. The maximum encoding time was soon raised to 68 minutes, satisfying Herbert Von Karajan's requirement that the disc be long enough to play back Beethoven's Ninth Symphony in its entirety.

Imagine, a conductor dictating the length of a sound carrier. Then again, PolyGram was Philips' prinipal client: The idea behind the CD was that it would cut back on the number of returns for defective records, and additionally, and in some respects more importantly, it would replace vinyl with another carrier material. As a petroleum product, vinyl suffered the same fate as any other oil derivative during the 1970's.

Let us not forget as well: Karajan was indeed a maestro. Everywhere. Including the PolyGram HQ in Hannover. Rumor has it they were terrified of him. It is widely rumored that Peter Erdmann stopped riding a motorcycle to work during his tenure as Group president, so terrified was he that Von K. would speed along beside him on the Autobahn, and cut him off.

By 1979 the format arrived in its penultimate form, with a larger disk size than that desired by Philips and the European car stereo business which sought a disk that would fit into the existing dimension of car stereos in Europe. The larger diameter raised the playback time to 74 minutes, sixteen seconds.


First is the last of its kind

Apart from their adherence to a common standard, Philips and Sony chose different paths to the design of CD players. Sony aimed for a bit-for-bit assembly that was sixteen bits long, Philips retained the design that it had developed for its first prototype in 1978. By 1980, the 14 bit decoder had been refined to the point where it easily outperformed what was feasible using a sixteen bit word length at the time. In the original Philips design, the playback unit ignores the two least significant bits, adding them at the assembly stage, during error correction.

Fourteen bits of retrieval obviously worked better than sixteen, and it allowed Philips to develop a robust error correction system that was more capable of playing damaged or imperfect discs. Philips introduced sixteen bit players in late 1983 that had all of the error correction capabilities of the CDP-101. The top of the line model, the CDP-303 had a sliding tray that brought the entire transport out to permit a disc to be more conveniently loaded.

The CDP-303 was my first CD player, and I was immediately impressed by its open, non-fatiguing sound. Years later, I had a chance to listen to a CDP-101, which I took to be inferior back in 1984 for its truncated playback, and discovered that all of the qualities that had impressed me with the 303 were present in the 101.

Quality Control

The CDP-101 was put into production in late 1981. The format's launched was planned for August, 1982, and Philips wanted to ensure that the CD player would be available in sufficient quantity to meet the expected demand by both consumers and the music industry itself.

PolyGram companies would each receive several units prior to the launch to permit quality control checks to be made in each market where CDs were to be distributed. At the time, 'QC' was practiced by all PolyGram companies. Many did not manufacture records, using local pressing plants for this purpose. QC was applied in all markets to both locally manufactured records, and to those made in Europe by PolyGram in Hannover. By 1984, most PolyGram QC departments had sizable collections of commercially available CD players, routinely testing the playback success of the machines against their own reference, a Philips CD player. Most initial players were incapable of playing a damaged disc.

Sonic quality issues aside, the average non-Philips player did a passable job with a defect free disc. Toshiba's 16 bit player was the first to match the performance of Sony's first machine. Long term enthusiasts will recall the player: Barely. The first stab that Toshiba took at digital was presented in a black box with a disk that spun vertically. Dual liked Toshiba's unit, and used the design minus its dreadful display, which they replaced with one that is among the prettiest that I have seen.


 

Diminutive in size, the FD1000 is a heat producer. The player's rear panel is occupied by a heat sink, its interior is filled with r.f. shielded circuitry. The aluminum top panel provides additional heat dissipation.

By its third generation of CD players (1985), Philips had reduced circuit density by 90%, and power consumption by one-half.


Form as evidence of necessity acknowledged


Functionally, the FD1000 is as obvious as it gets. The CD is a top top loader that has no moving parts, except the disc motor and its mass loader, and the laser assembly. Its control interface allows songs to be programed, but figuring out how to do so without an owner's manual may pose something of a challenge.

The FD1000 is a quiet player, and it has soundproofing features not often found in contemporary players; a dampened interior; a plexiglas cover of some mass. The machine plays silently, providing music without any mechanically induced sonic crap along for the ride.  

Indeed the CDP-101 was considered to be such a winner that a number of British firms adopted it as a transport for their own CD players. Philips kept it in production far beyond its consumer lifespan to meet the demand.

Keeping your ears intact

The FD1000 that I have described as an item of historical interest is largely one itself. In the not too distant past my unit would play any disc. Now it won't. It will play a PDO disc and a Nimbus disc without hesitation. It won't play anything else.

So, I can listen to Stockhausen on DGG, Widor on Philips, Oldfield's Amarok on Virgin (PDO in Holland) or King Crimson's Starless and Bible black, and a handful of others that are on a PolyGram label, and, yes, were manufactured by PDO in Hannover. So, that means I'm okay with something like Dazzle Ships, by OMD, or any number of Virgin artiste CD's that I picked up when Virgin Records was distributed by PolyGram. If I knew what box they were in, I'd happily play them.

As for any of the cookie cutter CD's that make a sham of the Red Book, nada. No way. Not on a bad date. The once trusty MAGNAVOX will not oblige. The disk won't spin.

Sticking to the short list of disks that will play, I set about to do a comparison of the FD1000 with other machines that I have around, some new, some old, and with vinyl. My preferred choice for a quick and dirty subjective slovenly review was K.C. A good choice, since the source vinyl is a Japanese pressing that has remained quiet after many plays.

I ended up comparing the FD1000 against my Philips Bitstream, a non involving machine that is the least offensive of all of the players that I have on hand. It is very good at resolving detail, but the bass sounds lame on those occasions when I wish it wouldn't. I have a third generation fullbit Philips deck, but its playback success ranks as worse than the FD1000, and a Sony machine that works unfailingly but for errors, and the DUAL that I mentioned above, which could be nothing but a fullbit considering its vintage. None of the players come close to the FD1000 on the quiet test, and none could convey the sheer intensity of Starless that is so apparent on the record, and is encoded on disc.

Throwing in Widor (just to show 'em), I found matters to be a bit different. Mechanical noise levels aside, the Bitstream machine was equally successful in its presentation of the music, and was indistinguishable in its presentation of reverberation; something that the motley players smudge and make a mockery of.

The flagship from Philips seems undated. Its style is elegant, its form is basic. It is a highly sought after CD player, commanding figures in excess of $300.00 on eBay. The unit can still be serviced, which means that I could bring my unit into a Philips service facility and after a couple of Atlantic crossings it would return to me, like new.


ed.

02033